Skip to main content
G'day
!
G'day!
Sign in
or
register
eBay Deals
Find a Store
Help
Sell
Watch List
Expand watch list
My eBay
Expand My eBay
My eBay Summary
Recently Viewed
Bids/Offers
Watch List
Purchase History
Selling/Sold
Saved Feed
Saved Searches
Saved Sellers
My Garage
Sizes
My Messages
Get Exclusive Savings
Expand notifications
Please
sign in
to view notifications.
Expand cart
Loading...
eBay Home
Shop by category
All Categories
Search
Advanced
Maybelline New York Pencil Eye Shadows
You may also like
Maybelline New York Pressed Powder Eye Shadows
Maybelline New York Cream Eye Shadows
Maybelline New York Liquid Eye Shadows
Unbranded Pencil Eye Shadows
Urban Decay Pencil Eye Shadows
breadcrumb
eBay
Health & Beauty
Makeup
Eyes
Health & Beauty
Makeup
Eyes
Eye Shadow
Maybelline New York Pencil Eye Shadows
Related Searches
Maybelline Eyeshadow
Maybelline Eyeliner
Maybelline Eyebrow Pencil
Maybelline
Brow Pen Maybelline
Eyeliner Pencil
Maybelline Foundation
Eyeliner
Eyeshadow
Maybelline Lipstick
Maybelline Powder
Eye Liner
Shop by category
Eyes
Eye Shadow
Eye Shadow & Liner Combination
Eye Shadow Primer
Eyebrow Liner & Definition
Eyelash & Eyebrow Growth
Eyelash Extensions
Eyeliner
Mascara
Other Eye Makeup
All listings
Auction
Buy It Now
Best Offer
Sort: Best Match
Best Match
Time: ending soonest
Time: newly listed
Price + postage: lowest first
Price + postage: highest first
Distance: nearest first
List view
Gallery view
173 results
Sort: Best Match
Best Match
Time: ending soonest
Time: newly listed
Price + postage: lowest first
Price + postage: highest first
Distance: nearest first
2 filters applied
Brand: Maybelline New York
- Selected
Formulation: Pencil
- Selected
Brand
Maybelline New York
Avon
Bobbi Brown
Clinique
COVERGIRL
ELF
Eyeshadow
IT Cosmetics
JORDANA
L.A. COLORS
L'Oréal
Laura Mercier
M·A·C
Mally
Mary Kay
NYX
SeneGence
Unbranded
Urban Decay
wet n wild
Formulation
Pencil
Pressed Powder
Cream
Liquid
Loose Powder
Pigment
Crayon
Gel
Mousse
Pen
Type
Single
Palette
Duo
Not specified
Shade
Assorted
Brown
Gold
Blue
Green
Black
Neutral
Pink
Champagne
Silver
Purple
Red
Grey
White
Teal
Bronze
Peach
Vanilla
Violet
Not specified
Effect
Matte
Shimmer
Metallic
Glitter
Frost
Satin
Colour-Changing
Not specified
Condition
New with box
New without box
Price
Under AU $17
AU $17 to AU $25
Over AU $25
Filter
All Filters
MAYBELLINE Master Smoky Shadow Pencil with Smudger - CHOOSE SHADE - NEW
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
AU $40.65
Was:
AU $45.17
was AU $45.17
AU $29.35 postage
175 sold
Maybelline Brow Satin Double Ended Eyebrow Pencil
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
AU $16.41
AU $39.36 postage
2 watching
Vintage Maybelline Colorstix Powder Pencil Eye Shadow & Sharpener CARNATION
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
AU $13.48
AU $31.75 postage
MAYBELLINE BROW NATURAL DUO 2 IN 1 PENCIL AND POWDER LIGHT BROWN BRAND NEW
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
AU $14.90
Free postage
Click & Collect
2 x MAYBELLINE BROW NATURAL DUO 2 IN 1 PENCIL AND POWDER GREY BRAND NEW
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
AU $14.29
Free postage
MAYBELLINE COOL EFFECT SHADOW/LINER 1.9gm x1 (different colours available)
AU $3.95
AU $3.95 postage
2 x MAYBELLINE BROW NATURAL DUO 2 IN 1 PENCIL AND POWDER LIGHT BROWN BRAND NEW
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
AU $15.39
Free postage
3 watching
Mystery Beauty Bundles, 15 Items Per Box, You Choose Skin Tone, READ Description
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
AU $32.90
Was:
AU $50.61
was AU $50.61
AU $40.69 postage
BUY 1 GET 1 AT 20% OFF (Add 2 To Cart) Maybelline Color Tattoo 24HR Crayon
New (other)
·
Maybelline New York
(9)
AU $12.57
to
AU $30.35
AU $21.93 postage
MAYBELLINE BROW NATURAL DUO 2 IN 1 PENCIL AND POWDER GREY BRAND NEW
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
AU $13.90
Free postage
Click & Collect
MAYBELLINE COOL EFFECTS PENCIL SHADOW PRETTY COOL
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
AU $5.00
AU $2.95 postage
Vtg Maybelline SMOKEY TOPAZ Color Wand ll Powder Eye Shadow Liner Pencil 550WP4
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
AU $49.60
Was:
AU $70.86
was AU $70.86
or Best Offer
AU $30.81 postage
MAYBELLINE COOL EFFECTS PENCIL SHADOW COOL THE CHAMPAGNE
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
AU $5.00
AU $2.95 postage
Maybelline Color Tattoo Concentrated Crayon 740 Grey Crystal 0.08 oz
New (other)
·
Maybelline New York
(8)
AU $31.84
Was:
AU $52.28
was AU $52.28
AU $22.19 postage
3PK Maybelline Color Tattoo 3in1 Eyeshadow STIX Liner & Primer ~ I Am Unexpected
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
AU $30.28
or Best Offer
AU $22.15 postage
Maybelline Color Tattoo Eye Stix 10 I Am Shining Up To 24H Eyeshadow Shimmer
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
AU $16.85
or Best Offer
AU $21.75 postage
MAYBELLINE COOL EFFECTS PENCIL SHADOW COOL BLUES
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
AU $5.00
AU $2.95 postage
MAYBELLINE COOL EFFECTS PENCIL SHADOW COLD AS ICE
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
AU $5.00
AU $2.95 postage
FLAWED 2 x Maybelline Color Tattoo 24hr Crayon Eyeshadow Pink Parfait 705
New (other)
·
Maybelline New York
(9)
AU $21.92
AU $21.90 postage
Maybelline Color Tattoo 24hr Eye Stix ~ You Choose
New (other)
·
Maybelline New York
AU $12.15
AU $21.61 postage
Maybelline Color Tattoo Eye Stix 35 I am powerful
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
AU $7.65
or Best Offer
AU $29.97 postage
0 bids
14h 10m
MAYBELLINE COOL EFFECTS PENCIL SHADOW COLD FRONT
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
AU $5.00
AU $2.95 postage
3 PACK Maybelline MATTE COLOR TATTOO Eye Stix Shadow 110 I AM COZY, Sealed. LOT
New (other)
·
Maybelline New York
AU $50.23
AU $22.73 postage
MAYBELLINE COOL EFFECTS PENCIL SHADOW COLD CASH
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
AU $5.00
AU $2.95 postage
MAYBELLINE COOL EFFECTS PENCIL SHADOW ICE PRINCESS
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
AU $5.00
AU $2.95 postage
New Rare Maybelline Crystal Glitters Shadow Pencil Rhinestone Pink; Free S & H
New (other)
·
Maybelline New York
AU $18.54
AU $21.80 postage
Maybelline Crystal Glitters Shadow Pencil Glass Slipper 0.162 oz Rare HTF Shade
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
AU $30.55
Was:
AU $40.74
was AU $40.74
or Best Offer
AU $22.15 postage
Maybelline Crystal Glitters Shadow Pencil Glass Slipper 0.162 oz Rare HTF Shade
New (other)
·
Maybelline New York
AU $26.57
Was:
AU $35.43
was AU $35.43
or Best Offer
AU $22.03 postage
Maybelline Crystal Glitters Shadow Pencil Glass Slipper 0.162 oz Rare HTF Shade
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
AU $42.18
or Best Offer
AU $22.49 postage
Maybelline Color Tattoo 24HR Eye Stix Eyeshadow Crayon 30 I Am Courageous
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
AU $16.85
or Best Offer
AU $21.75 postage
3 Maybelline Crystal Glitters Shadow Pencil - Cocoa Glow - 0.162 oz HTF Shade
New (other)
·
Maybelline New York
AU $80.14
or Best Offer
AU $23.62 postage
Maybelline Crystal Glitters Shadow Pencil Glass Slipper 0.162 oz Rare HTF Shade
New (other)
·
Maybelline New York
AU $37.96
or Best Offer
AU $22.37 postage
Maybelline Twin Eye & Brow Wood Pencil Liners New & Sealed Mix & Match Quantity
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
AU $9.43
Was:
AU $11.79
was AU $11.79
AU $28.26 postage
Lot of 2 MAYBELLINE Crystal Glitters Shadow Pencil LILAC LIGHTNING 4.62 g NEW
New (other)
·
Maybelline New York
AU $28.82
or Best Offer
AU $22.10 postage
3 PACK Maybelline MATTE COLOR TATTOO Eye Stix Shadow 35 I AM POWERFUL, Sealed
New (other)
·
Maybelline New York
AU $50.23
AU $22.73 postage
Maybelline Color Tattoo 24hr Eye Stix, You Choose
New (other)
·
Maybelline New York
(1)
AU $16.85
AU $23.43 postage
3 PACK Maybelline MATTE COLOR TATTOO Eye Stix Shadow 70 I Am Extravagant, Sealed
New (other)
·
Maybelline New York
AU $50.23
AU $22.73 postage
3-Maybelline Color Tattoo 24H Eye Stix Sealed 0.049 oz 90 - I Am Rare
New (other)
·
Maybelline New York
AU $28.65
AU $22.10 postage
2 Maybelline Crystal Glitters Shadow Pencil - Rhinestone Pink - 0.162 oz
New (other)
·
Maybelline New York
AU $46.40
or Best Offer
AU $22.62 postage
5 watching
Maybelline Crystal Glitters Shadow Pencil - Rhinestone Pink - 0.162 oz RED DES
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
AU $30.35
or Best Offer
AU $33.88 postage
Maybelline eyeshadow Color Strike Cream to Powder
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
AU $9.24
AU $35.11 postage
1 Maybelline Color Tattoo 24h Eye Stix Eyeshadow 35 I Am Powerful #12
New (other)
·
Maybelline New York
AU $13.29
AU $21.65 postage
Only 1 left!
3 Maybelline Crystal Glitters Shadow Pencil - Bolt Of Blue - 0.163 oz
New (other)
·
Maybelline New York
AU $52.72
or Best Offer
AU $22.81 postage
MAYBELLINE Crystal Glitters Shadow Pencil DISCO BALL 4.62 g NEW
New (other)
·
Maybelline New York
AU $17.09
or Best Offer
AU $21.75 postage
MAYBELLINE THE ROCK NUDES EYE SHADOW PALETTE 12 COLOURS SILVER GREY GOLD PURPLE
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
(9)
AU $14.36
AU $28.27 postage
Maybelline Cool Effect Cooling Shadow Snow Bunny
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
(1)
AU $10.11
AU $15.18 postage
6 watching
Maybelline Color Tattoo 24hr Eye Stix #50- I Am Unique New Sealed
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
AU $16.85
or Best Offer
AU $21.75 postage
3 Sealed Maybelline Metallic Fx Sheer Chrome Eye Pencil STEELY GAZE Free Ship!
New (other)
·
Maybelline New York
AU $15.17
AU $21.70 postage
3 watching
Maybelline New York Color Tattoo 24hr Eye Stix, 45 I Am Giving | Matte Eyeshadow
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
AU $16.84
AU $21.75 postage
MAYBELLINE COLOR TATTOO 24 HR CONCENTRATED CRAYON 740 GREY CRYSTAL
New (other)
·
Maybelline New York
(9)
AU $33.73
AU $29.37 postage
Maybelline Color Tattoo 24hr Eye Stix, 50 I Am Unique #16
New (other)
·
Maybelline New York
AU $13.29
AU $21.65 postage
4 watching
(2) Maybelline Color Tattoo 24H Eye Stix Sealed 0.049 oz 90 - I Am Rare
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
AU $26.98
or Best Offer
AU $22.05 postage
(3) Maybelline Color Tattoo 24H Eye Stix Sealed 0.049 oz 50 - I Am Unique
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
AU $28.66
AU $22.10 postage
(Pack Of 3) Maybelline Great Line Eyeliner #400 VIOLET
New (other)
·
Maybelline New York
AU $25.29
AU $22.00 postage
MAYBELLINE COLOR SENSATIONAL MONO EYESHADOW - Shade 20 Bronze Addict + 25 Slate
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
(3)
AU $20.54
or Best Offer
AU $41.19 postage
Maybelline Eye Studio Color Tattoo Concentrated Crayon 700 Barely Beige Shadow
Brand new
·
Maybelline New York
(9)
AU $12.81
AU $21.63 postage
MAYBELLINE Crystal Glitters Shadow Pencil Polar Bear PINK 4.62 g NEW
New (other)
·
Maybelline New York
AU $15.18
AU $21.70 postage
1 Maybelline Color Tattoo 24h Eye Stix Eyeshadow 10 I Am Shining
New (other)
·
Maybelline New York
AU $16.85
AU $21.75 postage
3 Maybelline Crystal Glitters Shadow Pencil - Disco Ball - 0.162 oz
New (other)
·
Maybelline New York
AU $46.40
or Best Offer
AU $22.62 postage
2 Maybelline Crystal Glitters Shadow Pencil - Bolt Of Blue - 0.162 oz
New (other)
·
Maybelline New York
AU $37.96
or Best Offer
AU $22.37 postage
Results Pagination - Page 1
1
2
3
