Buy the real thing, it's better in the long run.
When you buy the right make of cartridges for your printer, you should always end up with a good product; because they are specially made by HP for HP printers/scanners & they advise that you use their make at all times.
I have, on occasion, used recycled HP cartridges but they aren't really good enough. They don't last as long for a start & can be flakey on the paper.
So I do my best to always buy HP and am glad to do so. Yes, they are more expensive than recycled or another make but diligent surfing will find you what you want at a lower price, which happened in this case. Always cheaper on the interweb that buying in a shop, even a large supermarket chain cannot do them at the price I paid.
Verified purchase: YesCondition: New