Reviews
"...[an] excellent book....Krebs unravels the musical subtleties that performers sense but do not always fully understand; performers have much to gain by applying Krebs's analytical approach to their interpretations of Schumann's music....This is analysis at its best: it is sensitively placedin a valid historical context, and solidly based on the real and heard elements in the score. The author supplies ample examples. Highly recommended for upper-level undergraduates through performers."--Choice, "...[an] excellent book....Krebs unravels the musical subtleties that performers sense but do not always fully understand; performers have much to gain by applying Krebs's analytical approach to their interpretations of Schumann's music....This is analysis at its best: it is sensitively placed in a valid historical context, and solidly based on the real and heard elements in the score. The author supplies ample examples. Highly recommended for upper-level undergraduates through performers."--Choice "This volume is a welcome contribution to the study of Schumann, especially for those interested in his music, but also for psychologists and others desiring to examine inferentially matters of personality through analysis of original documents."--Perceptual and Motor Skills "[This] is a very impressive piece of work. Though primarily a theoretical study, it casts its net considerably wider. Krebs is also sensitive to historical issues (precedents for Schumann's metrical style), philological matters (metrical revisions in the primary sources for Schumann's work), questions of performance practice, and even biography (possible relationships between Schumann's metrical techniques and his mental states). In addition, the book is written in an engaging and highly imaginative style."--John Daverio, School for the Arts, Boston University "This book is a unique contribution to Schumann studies; it should be read by anyone who is seriously interested in Schumann's music."--William Rothstein, Queens College and the Graduate Center, CUNY "[H]is accomplishment is no less than an imaginative reconstruction of the creative ferment of composing and theorizing in the early nineteenth century...Krebs's literary virtuosity in playing both sides of the fence does not smack of an ideologically loaded postmodernist approach to scholarship...[I]n daring to move creatively beyond the assurances of staid historical scholarship, Krebs also brings to bear a commanding knowledge of the repertoire, illustrated in copious analytical detail...In the course of such a wide-ranging interpretive journey, one could not ask for a more experienced and sensitive musical guide."--Music Theory Spectrum, "...[an] excellent book....Krebs unravels the musical subtleties that performers sense but do not always fully understand; performers have much to gain by applying Krebs's analytical approach to their interpretations of Schumann's music....This is analysis at its best: it is sensitively placed in a valid historical context, and solidly based on the real and heard elements in the score. The author supplies ample examples. Highly recommended for upper-level undergraduates through performers."--Choice"This volume is a welcome contribution to the study of Schumann, especially for those interested in his music, but also for psychologists and others desiring to examine inferentially matters of personality through analysis of original documents."--Perceptual and Motor Skills"[This] is a very impressive piece of work. Though primarily a theoretical study, it casts its net considerably wider. Krebs is also sensitive to historical issues (precedents for Schumann's metrical style), philological matters (metrical revisions in the primary sources for Schumann's work), questions of performance practice, and even biography (possible relationships between Schumann's metrical techniques and his mental states). In addition, the book is written in an engaging and highly imaginative style."--John Daverio, School for the Arts, Boston University"This book is a unique contribution to Schumann studies; it should be read by anyone who is seriously interested in Schumann's music."--William Rothstein, Queens College and the Graduate Center, CUNY"[H]is accomplishment is no less than an imaginative reconstruction of the creative ferment of composing and theorizing in the early nineteenth century...Krebs's literary virtuosity in playing both sides of the fence does not smack of an ideologically loaded postmodernist approach to scholarship...[I]n daring to move creatively beyond the assurances of staid historical scholarship, Krebs also brings to bear a commanding knowledge of the repertoire, illustrated in copious analytical detail...In the course of such a wide-ranging interpretive journey, one could not ask for a more experienced and sensitive musical guide."--Music Theory Spectrum, "[H]is accomplishment is no less than an imaginative reconstruction of the creative ferment of composing and theorizing in the early nineteenth century...Krebs's literary virtuosity in playing both sides of the fence does not smack of an ideologically loaded postmodernist approach toscholarship...[I]n daring to move creatively beyond the assurances of staid historical scholarship, Krebs also brings to bear a commanding knowledge of the repertoire, illustrated in copious analytical detail...In the course of such a wide-ranging interpretive journey, one could not ask for a moreexperienced and sensitive musical guide."--Music Theory Spectrum, "This book is a unique contribution to Schumann studies; it should be read by anyone who is seriously interested in Schumann's music."--William Rothstein, Queens College and the Graduate Center, CUNY, "...[an] excellent book....Krebs unravels the musical subtleties that performers sense but do not always fully understand; performers have much to gain by applying Krebs's analytical approach to their interpretations of Schumann's music....This is analysis at its best: it is sensitively placed in a valid historical context, and solidly based on the real and heard elements in the score. The author supplies ample examples. Highly recommended for upper-level undergraduates through performers."-- Choice "This volume is a welcome contribution to the study of Schumann, especially for those interested in his music, but also for psychologists and others desiring to examine inferentially matters of personality through analysis of original documents."--Perceptual and Motor Skills "[This] is a very impressive piece of work. Though primarily a theoretical study, it casts its net considerably wider. Krebs is also sensitive to historical issues (precedents for Schumann's metrical style), philological matters (metrical revisions in the primary sources for Schumann's work), questions of performance practice, and even biography (possible relationships between Schumann's metrical techniques and his mental states). In addition, the book is written in an engaging and highly imaginative style."--John Daverio, School for the Arts, Boston University "This book is a unique contribution to Schumann studies; it should be read by anyone who is seriously interested in Schumann's music."--William Rothstein, Queens College and the Graduate Center, CUNY "[H]is accomplishment is no less than an imaginative reconstruction of the creative ferment of composing and theorizing in the early nineteenth century...Krebs's literary virtuosity in playing both sides of the fence does not smack of an ideologically loaded postmodernist approach to scholarship...[I]n daring to move creatively beyond the assurances of staid historical scholarship, Krebs also brings to bear a commanding knowledge of the repertoire, illustrated in copious analytical detail...In the course of such a wide-ranging interpretive journey, one could not ask for a more experienced and sensitive musical guide."-- Music Theory Spectrum, "This volume is a welcome contribution to the study of Schumann, especially for those interested in his music, but also for psychologists and others desiring to examine inferentially matters of personality through analysis of original documents."--Perceptual and Motor Skills, "...his accomplishment is no less than an imaginative reconstruction of the creative ferment of composing and theorizing in the early nineteenth century....In the course of such a wide-ranging interpretative journey, one could not ask for a more experienced and sensitive musical guide."--Music Theory Spectrum, "[This] is a very impressive piece of work. Though primarily a theoretical study, it casts its net considerably wider. Krebs is also sensitive to historical issues (precedents for Schumann's metrical style), philological matters (metrical revisions in the primary sources for Schumann's work),questions of performance practice, and even biography (possible relationships between Schumann's metrical techniques and his mental states). In addition, the book is written in an engaging and highly imaginative style."--John Daverio, School for the Arts, Boston University
Synopsis
This book presents a theory of metrical conflict and applies it to the music of Schumann, thereby placing the composer's distinctive metrical style in full focus. It describes the various categories of metrical conflict that characterize Schumann's work, investigates how states of conflict are introduced and then manipulated and resolved in his compositions, and studies the interaction of such metrical conflict with form, pitch structure, and text. Throughout the text, Krebs intersperses his own theoretical assertions with Schumannesque dialogues between Florestan and Eusebius, who comment on the theory at hand while also discussing and illustrating relevant aspects of "their" metrical practices., Fantasy Pieces examines from several vantage points a vital life-force of Robert Schumann's music, namely metrical conflict. Harald Krebs's imaginative yet rigorous study makes use of Schumann's fascinating projections of his own personality--the characters Florestan and Eusebius--as one means of addressing the biographical and aesthetic context of the music.In counterpoint with the remarks of these personae, Krebs develops an original theory of metrical conflict by adapting the concepts of consonance and dissonance to metrical analysis. He investigates how states of metrical dissonance arise, and shows how they are manipulated and resolved in the course of compositions. He offers new methods for understanding the metrical progressions of entire works or movements, and studies the interaction of metrical conflict with form, with pitch structure, and with the texts of Schumann's vocal works. Krebs includes a wealth of illustrations from the whole range of Schumann's work and offers numerous insights important for performance. In the final chapter, he provides richly detailed studies of pieces by Schumann in various genres, interspersing them with shorter discussions of music by Berlioz, Chopin, Clara Schumann, Ives, and Schoenberg.This is a book that will appeal not only to students and scholars of music theory, but to all musicians interested in the life, work, and unique personality of Robert Schumann., Fantasy Pieces examines from several vantage points a vital life-force of Robert Schumann's music, namely metrical conflict. Harald Krebs's imaginative yet rigorous study makes use of Schumann's fascinating projections of his own personality--the characters Florestan and Eusebius--as one means of addressing the biographical and aesthetic context of the music. In counterpoint with the remarks of these personae, Krebs develops an original theory of metrical conflict by adapting the concepts of consonance and dissonance to metrical analysis. He investigates how states of metrical dissonance arise, and shows how they are manipulated and resolved in the course of compositions. He offers new methods for understanding the metrical progressions of entire works or movements, and studies the interaction of metrical conflict with form, with pitch structure, and with the texts of Schumann's vocal works. Krebs includes a wealth of illustrations from the whole range of Schumann's work and offers numerous insights important for performance. In the final chapter, he provides richly detailed studies of pieces by Schumann in various genres, interspersing them with shorter discussions of music by Berlioz, Chopin, Clara Schumann, Ives, and Schoenberg. This is a book that will appeal not only to students and scholars of music theory, but to all musicians interested in the life, work, and unique personality of Robert Schumann.
