Widowed and pregnant Amish woman, Sarah Kurtz, is in dire financial circumstances. Relief comes unexpectedly when her late uncle leaves her his income-producing farm in Sugarcreek. After Sarah's baby is born, she leaves Lancaster County and moves to her new home, unaware there is a long-term tenant living in the adjoining grossdaddi haus. When she meets her disagreeable neighbor, Joshua Byler, her irritation with him is softened by his two children. Not wanting her daughter to be raised with one parent and siblings as she was, Sarah kws the only solution is to marry again. With Christmas looming, will Sarah find her prayers are answered? Or will she let Joshua Byler stand in her way of happiness?