Featured categories
All items

BUFFALO NICKELS BAG OF 500 PARTIAL DATE Bulk Lot Indian Head Coins 1913-1938
AU $323.50

12 Vintage Pocket Watches Rockford Hampden Hamilton & More For Parts No Reserve!
AU $46.2210 bids5d 15h 6m

1832 Dime Capped Bust PCGS VF 25 Freshly Graded Silver Coin 4521
AU $269.65

TIFFANY & CO Sterling Silver Atlas 1995 Bangle Cuff Bracelet with Pouch Box
AU $306.63

1836 Capped Bust 25c Quarter PCGS G04 Freshly Graded 5355
AU $192.60

2019 Cook Islands Woodstock 50 Years 1/4 oz 999 Gold Guitar Pick NGC MS70 COA
AU $1,462.25

1917 S Type 2 Standing Liberty Quarter PCGS Graded VF35 Silver Coin 5718
AU $254.24

GEORG JENSEN Sterling Silver Bowl Denmark #251 Beaded Rim 5.38 Troy Ounces
AU $577.81

ILLINOIS AMERICA Pocket Watch Model 3 18 Size Coin Silver Case No Reserve!
AU $6.553 bids6d 14h 6m

1853 Half Dollar Seated Liberty Arrows & Rays PCGS VF30 Graded Coin 6275
AU $437.60

1875 S 20 Cent Piece PCGS AG03 Graded Seater Liberty Twenty 20c 5298
AU $225.44

1944 S Standing Liberty Half Dollar PCGS MS64 White Freshly Graded Coin 6623
AU $175.65

1942 S Mercury Dime PCGS MS67 OGH Bright Lustrous Original Coin Wow 5042
AU $216.22

1903 Indian Head AU 58 BN NGC Graded Cent Coin Penny 2214
AU $60.09

1964 OGH SAMPLE PCGS Kennedy 1964 Silver Half Dollar Coin MS 6704
AU $53.93

1896 O MORGAN PCGS Graded XF45 Silver Dollar Coin 7242
AU $154.08

1890-CC MORGAN PCGS F12 Graded Silver Dollar F 12 Coin 7198
AU $331.28

1875 S Seated Liberty 20c PCGS Graded Cleaned G04 Twenty Cent Piece 5298
AU $237.73

1976 Bicentennial Council of the 13 Original States GOLD Medal Franklin Mint
AU $275.81

1823 Capped Bust 50c Half Dollar Fresh PCGS Fine Details Gouged Normal 3 6131
AU $177.20

1899 MORGAN PCGS Graded Cleaned AU Detail Silver Dollar Coin 7258
AU $380.59

2007-W $50 1/2 oz Proof Platinum Eagle 10th Anniversary Set NGC Reverse PF70
AU $2,765.79

1899 O BARBER DIME PCGS F12 Silver Coin 4819
AU $154.50

1929-S Standing Liberty Quarter PCGS Graded Coin AU 55 Sharp Coin! #5776
AU $246.53

1964 Half Dollar Kennedy Proof PR68 Accented Hair PCGS Graded Silver Coin 6801
AU $568.57

1922-1925 SET of Peace Dollars Silver Coin PCGS MS 63 Graded 7357 7360 7363 7365
AU $375.96

Four 4 Sterling Silver Souvenir Spoons Pikes Peak Texas Colorado Missouri 42 Gr
AU $152.54

Phil Niekro Signed Autographed Major League Baseball PSA/DNA Authentication
AU $169.49

1958 Franklin Half Dollar Toned Coin PCGS Graded MS 64 6674
AU $51.74

1917 D Type 1 Standing Liberty Quarter PCGS Graded VF25 Silver Coin 5708
AU $215.72

Ippolita Bangle Rock Candy Rose Gold Vermeil Sterling Silver Bangle Bracelet
AU $300.46

1899 MORGAN PCGS Graded AU53 Silver Dollar Nice Original Coin 7258
AU $360.55

1827 Capped Bust Half Dollar VF35 Square Base 2 PCGS Graded Silver Coin
AU $329.74

1837 Half Dollar VF30 PCGS Graded Silver Coin 6176
AU $368.26

1897 S BARBER DIME PCGS F 12 Fine Original Silver Coin 4814
AU $183.76

1923 Struck Through Obverse Error PEACE Silver Dollar MS63 PCGS Graded 7360
AU $244.99

13 Vintage Pocket Watches Illinois Waltham Capitol & More For Parts No Reserve!
AU $124.817 bids5d 15h 6m

1886 Indian Cent Type 2 PCGS VF 35 Freshly Graded Coin 92154
AU $213.70

Denny Mclain Signed Autographed Major League Baseball PSA/DNA Authentication
AU $152.54

1854 Seated Liberty Half Dollar PCGS Fine Details Scratch Silver Coin 6279
AU $135.59

1901 O Barber Half Dollar PCGS VG 08 Freshly Graded 6490
AU $153.30

BORNAND Pocket Watch 1886 Patty Cross Enamel Pendant Watch Mourning No Reserve
AU $16.184 bids5d 15h 6m

1832 Capped Bust Half Dollar PCGS VF25 SMALL Letters Graded Coin 6160
AU $268.10

1878-CC Morgan Dollar PCGS Graded Coin VG08 #7080
AU $308.15

1844 O Half Dime Seated Liberty PCGS VG Detail Key Date Silver Coin 4334
AU $383.67

29 Vintage Leather Watch Fobs John Deere IH Caterpillar Agriculture Collection
AU $454.55

1878 MORGAN 8TF PCGS Wheel Mark UNC Detail Silver Dollar Coin 7072
AU $443.76

TIFFANY & CO Sterling Silver Diamond T Square Wrap Bracelet with Box
AU $1,687.21
About us
Since 1989, American Rare Coin with over 200 years of numismatic experience on staff is one of the largest coin and precious metals dealers in the Midwest. We sell competitively priced PCGS and NGC Certified coins, all forms of gold and silver bullion, silver dollars, currency, and U.S. Proof/Mint.
Seller feedback (6,576)
- a***t (664)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseGreat Photos, Thorough Description, Discount Pricing, Instant Equity, Prompt Communication, Super Service, Secure Packaging, and Fast Shipping!!! Check-Out American Rare Coin and Collectibles' Inventory & give them Your Business!!! Shop the Golden Gopher State!!! A Great Source for Morgan Dollar VAMs!!! (:-)))--(((((::::
- h***l (1001)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseVery Happy! Received well packaged item very quickly. The item was the same as shown and described on website. Seller is an excellent communicator. 5 Stars Seller. Will do business again with this seller. A++
- a***h (1180)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseFast shipping, packaged very well, item exactly as described and at a great price. Seller is an asset to Ebay and A+++++ look forward to more dealings in the future, thanks again for a great looking coin.
- o***s (57)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseNice coin, exactly as described, well packaged and shipped quickly, great price! Thank you!! Highly recommend this seller!
- 2***h (1579)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseNice safe shipping and good packaging make for a solid transaction. The item was as described leading toward the value you would expect from American Rare Coin and Collectibles. Thank you.
- n***i (590)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseI am giving same feedback twice. Great communication, fast shipping, great packaging, accurate description AAAAA++++ all the way