12K items sold
853 followers
Contact

Browse our vast selection

Vintage to High End Modern!

Browse our vast selection

All items

About us

Welcome to Cardboard Legacy, the eBay home of one of Wisconsin’s premier sports-card shops! Since April 2020 we’ve been curating a collector-focused inventory that now tops 50,000 singles, sets, parallels, autos, relics, and graded gems spanning every era—from 1950s vintage legends to today’s hottest rookie chases in baseball, football, basketball, hockey, F1, soccer, and more. Our small family team packs five years of flawless service (nearly 5,000 perfect feedback and counting) into every transaction: lightning-fast replies, detailed card photos, accurate descriptions, and same- or next-business-day shipping in our signature multi-layer protective mailers. Buy with confidence knowing your cards are encapsulated in fresh sleeves, rigid holders, team bags, and Gemini-style cardboard—then double-boxed or bubble-wrapped for ultimate safety. Combine shipping to save, join our regular auctions for bargain steals, or message us to bundle a custom lot.
Location: United StatesMember since: 31 January 2004Seller: cardboardlegacystore

Detailed seller ratings

Average for the last 12 months
Accurate description
5.0
Reasonable postage costs
4.9
Postage speed
5.0
Communication
5.0

Seller feedback (5,382)

  • t***s (1405)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    I’ve been a passionate sports card buyer, seller and personal collector for over 30 years and I’m leaving this honest review without solicitation. This seller offers some of the best quality sports cards of the latest superstars on the market. My order was shipped quickly and arrived a few days later. It was packaged well and arrived undamaged and exactly as described, in mint condition. After a thorough inspection, it’s off to get graded. Great value for premium sports cards. Thank you 🤟🏽
  • b***b (1863)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    Beautiful card. Card arrived just as advertised. Card was shipped in a top loader and in a padded envelope, to ensure safe arrival which I appreciate a lot. I feel like I got a great value for the price I paid for the card. Great quality. Fantastic transaction great communication. A+A+A+
  • k***a (707)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    Order arrived exactly as described. Funny, shipping was $5 for this. I have paid the same for a card to arrive in an envelope with a .97 stamp on it and this arrived nicely packaged (as described) in a nice little box with protective packaging inside. Hats off to an excellent Seller !
  • j***j (3456)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past month
    Verified purchase
    Absolutely outstanding experience! The prices were some of the best I’ve seen—fair, honest, and clearly listed with care. The cards arrived quickly and were packaged so thoughtfully, with protection that shows they truly value the condition of each card and the happiness of their buyers. Everything from the packaging to the delivery speed, was perfect. 100000% recommend this seller A+++++++++++
  • h***l (174)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    Absolutely thrilled with this purchase! The card arrived in mint condition, exactly as described (if not better). Great eye appeal, sharp corners, and vibrant colors—clearly well cared for. Packaging was professional and secure, ensuring the card stayed pristine in transit. Given the quality and presentation, this was a tremendous value. A+++ seller—highly recommended to any serious collector!
  • 1***3 (665)- Feedback left by buyer.
    Past 6 months
    Verified purchase
    I couldn't recommend this seller more! They made an offer almost immediately after I watch the item. Shipping was very fast. The card arrived in a box and then inside it was packaged between a bubble wrap mailer. Extremely well packed and arrived in as described condition. Highly recommend this seller and will do business with again. Thank you.

About us

Use this space to tell other eBay members about yourself and what you’re passionate about. Give people more reasons to follow you!960/1000