Skip to main content
Collect Indy

Collect Indy

1.6K items sold
158 followers
Contact

Featured categories

Newly listed

See all

  • 2018 UK £0.50 Silver Proof Coin | Representation of the People Act of 1918

    AU $128.05

  • 2022 UK £0.50 Silver Proof Coin | Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth II w/ COA

    AU $128.05

  • 2019 Tower of London | Ceremony of the Keys | £5 Silver Proof | .925 Sterling

    AU $150.66

  • 2019 Tower of London | Yeoman Warders | £5 Silver Proof | .925 Sterling Silver

    AU $225.99

  • 2016 CANADIAN MAPLE LEAVES $10 | 99.99% SILVER COIN w/ COA

    AU $52.72

  • 1999 P & D Susan B Anthony 2 Coin Mint Set W/ Yellowstone Card- OGP!

    AU $19.57

Collect Indy!!!

Shop now
Collect Indy!!!

All items

2012-P Chester Arthur Presidential Dollar Bank Roll Sealed BU 25 Coins

AU $55.73

Space Jam 1996 Upper Deck All-Star Cast Boxed Set 20 Premium Oversized Cards

AU $226.01

Franklin Mint 1971 Apollo 14 Traveled to Moon Silver Limited Edition Mini-Coin

AU $45.20

1999 P & D Susan B Anthony 2 Coin Mint Set W/ Yellowstone Card- OGP!

AU $19.57

2017 | American Liberty 225th Anniversary Silver Medal

AU $150.66

2011 Ulysses S. Grant Presidential Dollar Bank Roll Sealed BU 25 Coins

AU $55.73

2008 John Quincy Adams Presidential Dollar Bank Roll Sealed BU 25 Coins

AU $55.73

2016 CANADIAN MAPLE LEAVES $10 | 99.99% SILVER COIN w/ COA

AU $52.72

2008 UD Premier Stitchings Bob Sanders Huge Patch Defensive MVP Colts /15 (cons)

AU $113.00

1958 Topps Baseball # 320 - Whitey Ford - New York Yankees - Decent Centering

AU $75.34

2022 UK £0.50 Silver Proof Coin | Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth II w/ COA

AU $128.05

Lot of (3) Vintage 1938 Boston Bees Photos Vincent DiMaggio, Cuccinello, West

AU $75.34

1957 Topps Dale Long - PSA 4 VG-EX - Well Centered

AU $45.20

1999 Bowman Baseball #365 Marcus Giles - Beckett 9.5 - Gem Mint - Rookie Card

AU $45.20

1988 Topps Football #3365 Stephone Paige PSA 9

AU $30.13

1989 Upper Deck #1 Ken Griffey Jr. Rookie Card RC HOF - CSG 8.5 - NM/Mint+

AU $301.34

2019 Tower of London | Ceremony of the Keys | £5 Silver Proof | .925 Sterling

AU $150.66

2008 UD Premier Stitchings - Bob Sanders - Large Patch - Colts #d /15 (cons)

AU $113.00

1984 Topps Baseball #8 Don Mattingly Rookie Card RC HOF - CSG 8 - NM/Mint

AU $75.34

2006 Donruss Leaf Limited Dallas Clark Monikers Auto /44 Colts (cons)

AU $75.34

2019 Tower of London | Yeoman Warders | £5 Silver Proof | .925 Sterling Silver

AU $225.99

1964 Topps #9 Aaron/McCovey/Mays/Cepeda - CSG 4.5 - NL Home Run Leaders - HOFers

AU $226.01

2011 Panini Timeless Treasures Reggie Wayne Auto - Indianapolis Colts /15 (cons)

AU $150.67

2012 Topps Triple Threads Ty Hilton Rookie Auto Patch - Colts - /99 (cons)

AU $90.40

1983 Topps Baseball #83 Ryne Sandberg Rookie Card RC HOF - CSG 7.5 - Near Mint+

AU $75.34

1999 SkyBox E-X Century Edgerrin James E-xtraordinary PSA 9 - Mint - HOF (cons)

AU $75.34

2006 Playoff Signature Proof Dallas Clark Auto Colts /50 (cons)

AU $75.34

1958 Topps Baseball #419 Bobby Shantz - New York Yankees - CSG 7 Near Mint

AU $105.47

1999 Bowman Baseball #304 Shea Hillenbrand - Beckett 9.5 - Gem Mint Rookie Card

AU $45.20

1999 Bowman Baseball #84 Mike Nannini - Beckett 9.5 - Gem Mint - Rookie Card

AU $30.13

2012 Leaf Sports Icons Cut Signatures 1/1 Isiah Thomas CM Newton Auto HOF RARE!!

AU $226.01

1999 Bowman Baseball #440 Carl Crawford - Beckett 9.5 - Gem Mint - Rookie Card

AU $45.20

2008 Upper Deck Icons Dallas Clark Auto Colts /35 (cons)

AU $90.40

T25 Between The Acts - Actors - Robert Hilliard PSA 1.5

AU $37.67

1999 Bowman Baseball #358 Michael Restovich - Beckett 9.5 - Gem Mint Rookie Card

AU $30.13

2006 Flair Showcase Fresh Ink Reggie Wayne Auto - Indianapolis Colts (cons)

AU $75.34

1969 Topps #82 Richie Hebner / Al Oliver - CSG 7.5 - Pirates Rookies

AU $150.67

1999 Bowman Baseball #214 Alex Escobar - Beckett 9.5 - Gem Mint - Rookie Card

AU $30.13

1999 Bowman Baseball #115 Choo Freeman - Beckett 9.5 - Gem Mint - Rookie Card

AU $30.13

1999 Bowman Baseball #200 Austin Kearns - Beckett 9.5 - Gem Mint - Rookie Card

AU $30.13

2005 Duke Snider UD Portraits Autograph 8x10 - Upper Deck - Dodgers

AU $150.67

1999 Bowman Baseball #305 J. D. Closser - Beckett 9.5 - Gem Mint - Rookie Card

AU $30.13

1999 Bowman Baseball #416 Ryan Langerhans - Beckett 9.5 - Gem Mint - Rookie Card

AU $45.20

1958 Topps Baseball #440 Eddie Mathews - Milwaukee Braves - CSG 6 Ex/NM

AU $226.01

2018 UK £0.50 Silver Proof Coin | Representation of the People Act of 1918

AU $128.05

1996-97 Collector's Choice #26 Michael Jordan - Bulls Victory Tour - CSG Mint 9

AU $75.34

1911 T201 MECCA DOUBLE FOLDERS HUGGINS / BRESNAHAN PSA EX 4 HOF CARDINALS

AU $753.35

2012 Rookie and Stars Rookie Material Andrew Luck Patch Auto Colts /499 (cons)

AU $226.01
Items per page
See all

About us

Collect Indy is Indiana's Premier Collectible Store. Here to help you sell everything from Sports Cards and Vinyl to Stamps and Postcards.
Location: United StatesMember since: 20 January 2021Seller: collectindy

Feedback ratings

Last 12 months

Positive56- positive Feedback in last 12 months
Neutral0- neutral Feedback in last 12 months
Negative0- negative Feedback in last 12 months

Detailed seller ratings

Average for the last 12 months

Accurate description
5.0
Reasonable postage costs
4.8
Postage speed
5.0
Communication
5.0

Seller Feedback (867)

f***s (431)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Item as described, fast shipping, 5⭐️ seller, thank you!
i***v (42)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past year
Verified purchase
I got the item as described for a good price. A good seller Indeed. Good experience
d***d (2206)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Accurate description, fast delivery, very professional. Thanks!
f***0 (851)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Quick shipping, good communication, an nice easy transaction. Thanks! Recommended seller - A+
s***v (597)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Item as described, fast shipping, would buy from again!!!
g***3 (179)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Amazing shipping and packaging and would love to do business with him again thank you
See all Feedback