Skip to main content
The Collecting Paradise Store

The Collecting Paradise Store

13K items sold
360 followers
Contact

Rookie Cards

1984 Topps JOHN ELWAY #63 Denver Broncos HOF RC SP PSA 5 Excellent Great Color

AU $67.70

1991 Topps Stadium Club BRETT FAVRE #94 Rookie Near Mint+ BGS 7.5

AU $42.09

2016 Panini Virginia Cavaliers Full Set MATT SCHAUB RALPH SAMPSON RYAN ZIMMERMAN

AU $19.50

1998 Upper Deck PEYTON MANNING #1 Rookie Card Rare Colts SP RC NM-Mint PSA 8

AU $75.23

1997 Topps Chrome Refractor TONY GONZALEZ #24 Rookie Rare SP RC NM-Mint PSA 8

AU $903.54

DANNY WHITE Signed 1977 Topps #284 Rookie Cowboys SP RC PSA/DNA Perfect 10 Auto

AU $210.77

1972 Topps JIM PLUNKETT #65 New England Patriots RC SP PSA 4 VG-EX Great Color

AU $49.62

2001 Donruss Classics Timeless Tributes MICHAEL VICK Rare Falcons SP RC #/100

AU $90.29

1999 Flair Showcase EDGERRIN JAMES RC Legacy Collection Row 3 Rare SP #/99 PSA 9

AU $444.28

2001 Private Stock Titanium MICHAEL VICK QUINCY CARTER Rare Dual Jersey SP RC

AU $22.52

2004 SP Authentic BARRY SANDERS K. Jones ROY WILLIAMS RC Triple Auto #/10 PSA 9

AU $1,347.89

2020 Panini Chronicles Draft Picks Spectra JUSTIN HERBERT #4 RC Gem Mint PSA 10

AU $90.29

1997 Fleer Ultra COREY DILLON Platinum Medallion Rookie SP Rare RC 1:100

AU $149.10

1997 Flair Showcase ANTOWAIN SMITH Row 0 Legacy Collection RC SP /100 Rare PSA 9

AU $225.83

2001 Quantum Leaf Rookie Revolution DAVID TERRELL Auto Rookie #/50 Rare RC SP

AU $75.23

1998 Bowman Chrome CURTIS ENIS #20 Rookie Card SP RC NM-Mint+ SGC 92 (8.5)

AU $16.49

1998 UD SP Authentic CURTIS ENIS #7 Rookie Card #/2000 RC NM-Mint+ SGC 92 (8.5)

AU $37.58

2008 Bowman Chrome Rookie Autographs Silver RASHARD MENDENHALL Auto RC SP #/10

AU $195.71

RANDALL MCDANIEL Signed 1989 Topps Traded #54T Rookie HOF RC SP Auto PSA/DNA

AU $225.83

1999 Leaf Certified Mirror Red Uncut Sheet EDGERRIN JAMES RC MARINO ELWAY FAVRE

AU $1,505.95

1999 Flair Showcase CHARLIE BATCH Legacy Collection Row 3 Rare #/99 PSA 10 Pop 1

AU $444.28

1960 Fleer LOU RYMKUS #80 Houston Oilers Rare Error FRAN CURCI RC #11 Wrong Back

AU $45.11

1999 Metal Universe Precious Metal Gems FRED VINSON #234 PMG #/50 SP RC BGS 8.5

AU $677.64

2000 SkyBox Premium COREY SIMON Star Rubies Extreme RC Rare SP #/50

AU $135.47

1960 Fleer MEL BRANCH #100 RC Dallas Texans Rare Error BOB MCNAMARA Wrong Back

AU $45.11

2015 Panini USC Trojans 77 Card Full Set FRANK GIFFORD TROY POLAMALU RONNIE LOTT

AU $22.52

1998 Upper Deck SP Authentic AHMAN GREEN Rookie #27 Rare Seahawks RC #/2000

AU $75.23

1999 Fleer Tradition Trophy Collection MIKE CLOUD RC SP #/20 Rare PSA 5 Pop 1

AU $225.83

RICK UPCHURCH Signed 1977 Topps #301 Rookie Broncos SP Slabbed Auto RC PSA/DNA

AU $105.35

2016 Panini Kansas Jayhawks 49 Card Set WILT CHAMBERLAIN GALE SAYERS JOEL EMBIID

AU $19.50

1996 Collector's Edge Presidents Reserve Uncut Sheet DAN MARINO CRIS CARTER +23

AU $150.53

1998 Fleer Brilliants RANDY MOSS #140 Rookie Card Vikings HOF RC Mint SGC 96 (9)

AU $52.64

JAMES LOFTON Signed 1979 Topps #310 Slabbed Auto Rookie Card Packers SP RC BAS

AU $150.53

2015 Panini Cal Golden Bears 50 Card Set AARON RODGERS JASON KIDD MARSHAWN LYNCH

AU $19.50

2016 Panini Tennessee Volunteers Set PEYTON MANNING BERNARD KING TODD HELTON

AU $19.50

2004 SP Authentic GREG JONES On-Card Auto Rare 4 Color Patch RC #/799

AU $88.86

2001 Pacific Prism Atomic Blue MICHAEL VICK Rookie #151 Die Cut Rare SP RC #/19

AU $225.83

1972 Topps LYLE ALZADO #106 Denver Broncos RC SP PSA 5.5 Excellent+ Great Color

AU $51.13

2001 Fleer Ultra Platinum Medallion CHRIS CHAMBERS RC Rare Miami Dolphins SP /25

AU $112.88

2005 Leaf Rookies & Stars TROY WILLIAMSON Freshman Orientation Patch SP RC #/100

AU $37.62

1999 Collectors Edge Advantage DAUNTE CULPEPPER Blue Ink Numbered Auto RC SP /40

AU $67.70

2004 Ultimate Collection CHRIS PERRY On Card Auto RC #/250 BGS 9.5/10 Low Pop

AU $60.21

1999 Score RICKY WILLIAMS Auto RC 2001 Originals Buyback Rare SP /45 BGS 7.5

AU $149.10

1960 Fleer JIM MATHENY #122 RC Houston Oilers Rare Error BILL KRISHER Wrong Back

AU $45.11

2012 Topps Five Star Rainbow ISAIAH PEAD Auto 3 Color Patch RC SP Rams #/25

AU $52.64

2005 UD Foundations RODDY WHITE CHRIS HENRY MARK BRADLEY Triple Auto RC SP #/75

AU $105.35

1960 Fleer JIM YATES #31 RC Houston Oilers Rare Error BUDDY ALLEN #48 Wrong Back

AU $45.11

2002 Donruss Gridiron Kings MIKE WILLIAMS Black Gold Foil Rare SP Bills RC #/100

AU $14.98
Items per page
See all

About us

Welcome to the Collecting Paradise Store. We sell Baseball, Basketball, Football, and Hockey cards, as well as autographed memorabilia. We also at times will sell vintage Golden, Silver, & Bronze Age Comic Books, Stamps, Coins, and many other collectibles. All singles want lists are welcome!
Location: United StatesMember since: 09 March 2001Seller: collectingparadise

Feedback ratings

Last 12 months

Positive293- positive Feedback in last 12 months
Neutral0- neutral Feedback in last 12 months
Negative1- negative Feedback in last 12 months

Detailed seller ratings

Average for the last 12 months

Accurate description
5.0
Reasonable postage costs
5.0
Postage speed
5.0
Communication
5.0

Seller Feedback (8,744)

d***a (30)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past month
Verified purchase
Incredible packing. $25 slabbed card shipped in double cardboard,baggie, plenty of tape in a bubble bag. I hope to buy from these folks again. Great seller highly recommend
3***p (297)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Item received exactly as advertised, shipped quickly and was packed well, item was received with no damage. Great buying experience from this seller.
r***s (85)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past year
Verified purchase
Fantastic seller! Great communication, packaging was great. Seller really cares. Product is perfect. Delivered on everything. Highly recommend. Will be a return customer. A+ all around! Thank you!
d***h (574)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Extremely fast shipping, packaged to perfection, card arrived in perfect condition, card was as described. A++++ seller
t***8 (1651)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past 6 months
Verified purchase
Item was exactly as pictured and described. Shipment was fast and well protected. Seller communication was good.
f***o (95)- Feedback left by buyer.
Past year
Verified purchase
Excellent Seller. I have saved you as a seller. Quick shipment. Packaged very well. Product as described. Thank you.
See all Feedback