Featured categories
Newly listed
See allAll items

Magic the Gathering MTG Wilds of Eldraine Promo Pack Factory Sealed
AU $12.23

2023 Panini Donruss Optic Holo #244 CJ Stroud RC PSA 10
AU $244.93

MTG Lord of the Rings Tales of Middle Earth Draft Booster Box Italian
AU $290.86

Magic the Gathering MTG Streets of New Capenna Promo Pack Factory Sealed
AU $12.23

Magic the Gathering MTG Throne of Eldraine ELD Foil Promo Pack Factory Sealed
AU $24.48

Magic the Gathering MTG Mercadian Masques (MMQ) Booster Pack Factory Sealed
AU $76.53

2024 Topps Update Yellow Rainbow Foil US100 Paul Skenes Pirates RC PSA 10
AU $413.33

Magic the Gathering MTG Invasion (INV) Booster Pack Factory Sealed
AU $52.04

MTG Fallout Surge Foil #546 Overencumbered Rare Enchantment
AU $5.04

Pokemon SoulSilver Collection (L1) (2009) Meowth 053/070 Common Holofoil LP
AU $7.64

2025 Topps Now NBA Draft 1st Pick #D1 Copper Flagg Dallas Mavericks RC
AU $9.17

Panini Instant NFL Draft 2025 #NFLDN-7 Shedeur Sanders Cleveland Browns RC
AU $13.70

Magic the Gathering MTG Dominaria United Promo Pack Factory Sealed
AU $12.23

MTG Lord of the Rings Tales of Middle Earth Draft Booster Box French
AU $290.86

MTG Fallout Foil #99 Contaminated Drink Uncommon Instant
AU $3.05

2024 Topps Chrome Gold Raywave #201 Jung Hoo Lee RC 32/50 Arena Club 9.5
AU $306.17

Magic the Gathering MTG Dominaria United DMU Foil Box Topper Factory Sealed
AU $7.64

Magic the Gathering MTG Nemesis (NEM) Booster Pack Factory Sealed
AU $48.97

2024 Stars & Stripes Signature Material Prime SMCC Cam Cannarella 08/25 PSA 8
AU $260.24

Magic the Gathering MTG Fate Reforged Factory Sealed Booster Pack
AU $15.29

MTG Fallout Foil #274 Myriad Landscape Uncommon Land
AU $3.05

2024 Topps Sterling Swings Auto Relic Albert Pujols #SWAR-AP 09/15 PSA 7
AU $520.50

2021 Bowman Draft Chrome Genesis Henry Davis RC GNS-1 Pittsburgh Pirates
AU $3.05

2024 Allen & Ginter Mini Blue Framed Auto MAJCHO Jackson Chourio Rookie RC PSA 9
AU $382.72

2023-24 Panini Select Mezzanine Level #312 Gradey Dick Toronto Raptors Rookie RC
AU $2.74

1961 Topps Star Rookie Carl Yastrzemski #287 Boston Red Sox HOF PSA 4
AU $183.70

2024 Topps Stadium Club Derek Jeter #187 New York Yankees HOF
AU $2.74

MTG Fallout Extended Art #491 Clifftop Retreat Rare Land
AU $7.64

1995 Classic Rookies Autograph Petey Sessoms 1857/2135
AU $2.89

Magic the Gathering MTG March of the Machine Promo Pack Factory Sealed
AU $12.23

Magic the Gathering MTG Kaldheim KHM Foil Promo Pack Factory Sealed
AU $24.48

2024 Topps Update 89 Topps Auto 89BA2-AM Drew Millas Washington Nationals RC
AU $4.58

MTG Fallout Showcase #872 Prime Mirelurk Queen Rare Creature
AU $13.76

2018 Panini Prizm Silver #184 Shai Gilgeous-Alexander RC PSA 10
AU $2,447.95

MTG Lord of the Rings Jumpstart Booster Box Factory Sealed French Edition
AU $168.39

Magic the Gathering MTG Throne of Eldraine Promo Pack Factory Sealed
AU $12.23

2023 Bowman Draft Chrome Refractor 1st Paul Skenes BDC-14 Pirates PSA 9
AU $107.16

Magic the Gathering MTG Phyrexia All Will Be One Foil Promo Pack Factory Sealed
AU $24.48

MTG Fallout Foil #129 C.A.M.P. CAMP Uncommon Artifact Fortification
AU $3.51

2024 Topps Update #US155 Jackson Chourio Milwaukee Brewers Rookie RC
AU $2.74

Magic The Gathering MTG Duel Deck Heroes vs Monsters Factory Sealed Japanese
AU $45.91

Magic The Gathering MTG Shadows Over Innistrad Booster Pack Factory Sealed
AU $13.76

2021-22 Panini Chronicles Essentials #307 Anthony Edwards Minnesota Timberwolves
AU $2.89

2024 Topps Update Blue Sparkle Foil #US322 Roddery Munoz Florida Marlins 543/999
AU $2.89

Magic the Gathering MTG Zendikar Rising Promo Pack Factory Sealed
AU $12.23

MTG Ravnica Remastered Foil Retro Border #368 Izzet Charm Uncommon Instant
AU $3.05

MTG Fallout Foil #73 Bighorner Rancher Uncommon Creature Human Ranger
AU $3.97

2024 Topps Update #US169 Jackson Merrill San Diego Padres Rookie RC
AU $2.59
About us
Hi there. Thank you for checking out It's Just a Garage Sale. I started this business to sell off items that I didn't use anymore, then slowly started adding other items that I found along the way. This stuff is pretty cool, thank you for checking it out.
Store policies
Postage
Seller feedback (1,455)
- o***3 (3816)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseThank you I received my order card is in excellent pristine condition fast shipping and packaging order was delivered on time but received message order was delivered on june 16th but was I received order on June 23rd 2025 I highly appreciate your business and your awesome deals you have to offer not to mention the excellent secure packaging. Fast shipper and reliable card dealer/seller I definitely recommend buying from.
- j***e (497)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseSolid card from a solid seller. All aspects of the transaction were exactly what I was seeking. Condition was described accurately, price was right, packaging at a top level and the card has the quality and appearance that I view as essential. It was clear from the beginning that customer service is a priority with this seller. I would do business again anytime. Thank you. A++++++++++++
- p***o (240)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseA+++ Seller, perfect packaging, fast shipping. Item arrived as described. Very happy with the purchase. I will be visiting again soon!
- 7***n (1712)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseCard was well packaged & protected during quick delivery. Card matches description and is in excellent condition. Excellent value! Beautiful card! Good communications and great experience! Thank you! A++
- n***e (199)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseItem arrived timely, well-packed, and as advertised. A++ seller!
- t***s (1)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseGreat seller quickly shipped package was as described . I would recommend seller.