Featured categories
All items

Star Spangled War Stories #123 F (1965) Dinosaurs and Monsters. Silver Age DC
AU $38.14

Star Spangled War Stories #131 F+ (1966) Dinosaurs and Monsters. Silver Age DC
AU $51.88

Star Spangled War Stories #115 VG+ (1964) Dinosaurs and Monsters. Silver Age DC
AU $38.14

The Tick #1 F/VF (1988) 1st appearance! 1st printing. New England Comics
AU $152.61

IWA Star Studded Wrestling Bulgarian Blimp 4" wrestling figure (1985) Near Mint
AU $15.25

Eclipse CD2000 CD, radio. satelite. 5V Pre Outs, Powerful Head Unit. Works good
AU $122.08

Star Spangled War Stories #132 VG/F (1967) Dinosaurs and Monsters. Silver Age DC
AU $30.51

Justice League #1 NM- (1987) 1st app Maxwell Lord! Batman. Newsstand copy.
AU $24.40

Star Spangled War Stories #114 VG (1964) Dinosaurs and Monsters. Silver Age DC
AU $13.72

Star Spangled War Stories #115 VG+ (1964) Dinosaurs and Monsters. Silver Age DC
AU $30.51

Luke Cage Power-Man #19 VG/F (1974) 1st appearance of Cotton-Mouth. Romita cvr
AU $21.35

Star Spangled War Stories #124 VG (1965) Dinosaurs and Monsters. Silver Age DC
AU $30.51

BATMAN #308 CGC 9.8 (1979) 1st Tiffany Fox. Mister Freeze app. Highest Graded!
AU $558.59

Marvel Two In One #2 VF /NM (1977) 2nd app. Spider-Woman. Shang Chi, The Thing
AU $16.77

IWA Star Studded Wrestling Killer Klondike 4" wrestling figure (1985) Near Mint
AU $15.25

Swamp thing #160 VF/NM (1995) Vertigo Comics! Horror! Mark Millar
AU $6.09

Marvel Spotlight on The Spider-Woman #32 VF+ (1977) 1st app. Jessica Drew.
AU $122.08

Swamp thing #159 VF+ (1995) Vertigo Comics! Horror! Mark Millar
AU $4.56

Voltron 6" Die-Cast figure (1981) Toei Bandai. Action Figure
AU $70.19

House of Mystery #261 VF (1978) Classic Mike Kaluta cover Grim Reaper!
AU $70.19

Werewolf By Night #1 CGC 7.5 (1972) Mike Ploog cover. Continued from Spotlight 4
AU $419.70

Star Spangled War Stories #112 F+ (1964) Dinosaurs and Monsters. Silver Age DC
AU $45.77

The Tick #3 VF- (1989) 1st printing. New England Comics
AU $19.83

Toxic Horror Magazine #1 NM- (1989) Starlog Freddy Kreuger, Jason, Michael Myers
AU $42.72

Cable Blood #1 NM- (1993) signed and numbered by Art Thibert. Comes with COA
AU $25.93

Lady Death: The Harrowing #9 NM- (1998) Chaos comics! Horror!
AU $10.67

Swamp thing #156 VF (1995) Vertigo Comics! Horror! Mark Millar
AU $4.56

Swamp thing #157 VF+ (1995) Vertigo Comics! Horror! Mark Millar
AU $4.56

Lady Death: The Harrowing #7 NM- (1998) Chaos comics! Deodato cover
AU $10.67

House of Mystery #317 F+ (1983) I Vampire. Classic Mike Kaluta cover. Newsstand
AU $9.14

Swamp thing #155 NM (1995) Vertigo Comics! Horror! Mark Millar
AU $9.14

Twisted Tales #10 VF- (1982) Pacific Bruce Jones, Richard Corben, Wrightson
AU $27.46

Swamp thing #151 NM (1995) Vertigo Comics! Horror! Mark Millar
AU $9.14

Luke Cage Power-Man #49 NM- (1978) Iron Fist app. last solo issue. John Byrne
AU $76.30

Giant Size Chillers #1 F+ (1974) 1st Lilith. Dracula app. Bronze Marvel Horror
AU $102.24

Lady Death: The Harrowing #8 VF/NM (1998) Chaos comics! Deodato cover
AU $9.14

Midnight Tales #3 F+ (1973) Charlton Comics, Bronze Age Horror.
AU $12.19

Young Love #107 VG+ (1974) DC Comics 100 page Super Spectacular! Teenage Romance
AU $33.56

Luke Cage Power-Man #40 NM (1977) Avengers, Hero for Hire, Defenders
AU $27.46

The Monster Times #25 VF- (1973) Horror Newspaper The Fly, Werewolves, King Kong
AU $38.14

Lady Death: The Harrowing #5 VF/NM Sketch variant (1998) Chaos comics!
AU $13.72

Swamp thing #145 NM (1994) Vertigo Comics! Horror! Justice League Dark.
AU $7.62

Detective Comics #567 VF/NM (1986) Batman story by Harlan Ellison. Newsstand
AU $7.62

Incredible Hulk #212 NM- (1977) 1st app. Constrictor. Serpent Society!
AU $41.19

Tank Girl Apocalypse #3 NM- (1996) Brian Bolland and Allan Grant. Dark Horse
AU $30.51

Detective Comics #535 NM (1984) 1st Jason Todd as Robin! Newsstand.
AU $38.14

Lady Death: Wicked Ways #4 NM- (1998) Chaos comics! Hughes and Pulido
AU $7.62

The Amazing Spider-Man Renew Your Vows #1 CGC 9.8 (2017) Cvr A. J Scott Campbell
AU $152.63
About us
Old Fashion PB and J comics is family owned and operated by husband and wife team of Patrick and Jessica Beam. With over 20 years experience buying and selling comics as well as 35+ years collecting we are as passionate about this hobby as our customers. We pride ourselves on accurate grading, safe packaging, fast shipping, and excellent customer service. We specialize in Comic Books from the Golden Age to this weeks new releases and look forward to earning your business as well as helping add to your collection!
Seller feedback (2,059)
- j***2 (2)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseOld Fashion PB and J Comics was fantastic! Stayed in communication before and after my purchase, shipped immediately and in great condition, well packaged for safety. It arrived exactly as pictured and detailed on their listing. Incredible service and value throughout. I have since saved them as a favorite seller and will continue to purchase from them in the future.
- a***s (267)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseGreat Seller! Fair pricing, accurate descriptions, secure packaging and quick shipping! A+
- i***r (655)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseGreat seller and fantastic new book! Took extra care in packaging-shipping and arrived perfectly. Just as described (actually even better!). Fiat price. Good communication . A+++++
- o***1 (1343)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseAWESOME SELLER! ALL THE COMICS were in Excellent condition, packaged EXTREMELY well, and shipped SUPER fast!!! Their prices are Very fair and the comics came in AT LEAST as good as described...if not Better. If you're looking for comics, I HIGHLY recommend this seller.
- e***a (507)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseGreat seller. Easy & friendly communication. Book as described. Shipped fast & very well packaged. Tops!
- z***0 (703)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchasePackage very well. Condition and appearance as described. Delivered very fast. Excellent seller. Will keep for future purchases.