Featured categories
Featured items
Madame Alexander GRETEL 8" Storyland 1992 Doll #454 Vtg Original Box MIB
AU $31.31
Vera Bradley Deco Daisy Little Princess Tote Bucket Style 8" x 7" Ruffles Red
AU $28.20
Ganz Webkinz GOOGLES Platypus Duck Goose Plush HM333 Blue 11" Stuffed NO CODE
AU $28.20
ONE LOVE Pride Tote Bag Rainbow LGBQT Gay Thalia + Pin Large 16' x 16" NEW NWT
AU $46.99
Vera Bradley LOLA Crossbody Hipster Brown Floral Bag 8" x 6" Quilted
AU $25.06
Best sellers
Planet of the Apes Plate 1967 Divided Kids DEKA Vtg 9.5" Plastic Melamine
AU $112.78
Muppet Babies 4 Disney Junior 2" Kermit Piggy Fozy Gonzo PVC Figures 2019
AU $23.48
Mattel HOOKS Ditto Bird Parrot Plush 16" Vtg 1987 Stuffed Pink Yellow Blue Korea
AU $43.86
PARIS Silk Scarf Laffaire Square 36" x 36" Large Black Gold Purple Vtg 80s
AU $75.19
Lucite Spoon Rest Kettle w/ Seashells 4" Vtg Blue Green Made USA
AU $18.00
Boehm Nativity Ornaments Greatest Gift Jesus Mary Joseph 3pc NIB 2004
AU $106.52
Top picks
Flintstones HollyRock Figures Barney & Dino 3.5" PVC Movie Set of 2 1992 EUC
AU $17.21
GRIMACE Plush 1980 McDonald's 8" Stuffed Vtg Purple Plastic Eyes Fast Food
AU $70.49
Bones Coffee Tote Canvas Bag Black Skeleton Grocery 15" x 16" Shopping Reusable
AU $56.39
Russ Berrie Monkey Chee Baby 9" Pacifier Vtg Plush Stuffed Red Korea
AU $31.33
Ty Beanie Buddies FLIP Cat White Plush 11" Soft Pink Bow Vtg 1999 Buddy Tylon
AU $46.98
Popular
Pepsi Collector Glass 1976 Sylvester Cat Tweety Bird Looney Tunes Tree Saw
AU $16.42
Applause Looney Tunes FROG Michigan 14" Plush Vtg Stuffed 1994 Top Hat
AU $23.48
BENDY Ink Machine Plush 8" PhatMojo 2017 Black Meatly NEW NWT
AU $37.59
Snoopy Bean Plush 5" Peanuts United Syndicate Butterfly Vtg 1968 Nut Shell
AU $37.59
Ty Beanie PEACHES Giraffe 6" Plush Stuffed Yellow Brown NWT
AU $23.48
All items
American Girl Pet Dog APRICOT Poodle Puppy 6" Posable Legs Blonde 2014 Retired
AU $12.52
Memorex Cassette Case Storage 15 Tapes Stor Rite Pink Plastic Vtg USA
AU $31.33
Fisher Price Puffalump Cat Yellow Soft Parachute Plush 16" Vtg 1986 Kitty *READ*
AU $31.33
Mattel POOCHIE Dog Pink Plush Vtg 1983 Love Jogging 8” Complete Outfit EUC
AU $117.48
HERSHEY Mrs Claus Kurt Adler 4" Ornament Vtg 1982 Grandma Chocolate Christmas
AU $12.53
Personality Pets Owl Wesleyan OWU Bishops Vtg 6" Collegiate Plush Bird Red 1950s
AU $78.31
Li Bien Angel Trumpeting 1999 Ornament Vtg 4" Purple Pier 1 Hand Painted & Box
AU $31.33
Louisville Slugger M Jacket Men’s Wool & Leather Medium Vtg Varsity Letterman
AU $233.40
Hallmark Mattel Rainbow Brite Doll 12" Vtg 1983 Plush Soft Taiwan**READ**
AU $20.35
Hallmark BEST BUDS Plant Flower Pot 2007 Ornament 3.5" Friend Garden w/o Box
AU $12.53
BeautiControl Eye Shadow Quad Warm WM 402 Eyeshadow NEW OLD STOCK
AU $21.93
Primal Women Cycling Jersey Large L Comcast Team 2019 Black Full Zip NWT
AU $39.14
Hallmark WINTER GARDEN 2004 Ornament 3.5" Window Birds Poinsettia Keepsake NIB
AU $18.78
Ed Kaplan DOODLE BEAR Pink Lollipop Candy 18" Vtg Blue Y2K Play Along
AU $28.20
Scentsy Buddy POSH Poodle Dog Pink 15" Stuffed Plush + Vanilla Scent Pack
AU $25.06
Playskool Snuzzles Bunny Mirror Belly 7" Rabbit Pastel Pink Vtg Plush 1997 RARE
AU $313.28
Hallmark Fabulous DECADE 1995 Seal & 1997 Hedgehog Series Lot 2 in Box
AU $18.80
ONE LOVE Pride Tote Bag Rainbow LGBQT Gay Thalia + Pin Large 16' x 16" NEW NWT
AU $46.99
Ganz Webkinz GOOGLES Platypus Duck Goose Plush HM333 Blue 11" Stuffed NO CODE
AU $28.20
GRIMACE Plush 1980 McDonald's 8" Stuffed Vtg Purple Plastic Eyes Fast Food
AU $70.49
Vera Bradley HILO MEADOW Lanyard ID Case Floral Snap Black NWOT
AU $28.20
Planet of the Apes Plate 1967 Divided Kids DEKA Vtg 9.5" Plastic Melamine
AU $112.78
24K Co SYLVESTER Cat Looney Tunes 1993 Plush 18" Vtg Stuffed Black White
AU $31.30
Classic Raggedy Ann Doll 2007 Plush 7" Applause NWT + 14" Handmade Doll
AU $31.33
BENDY Ink Machine Plush 8" PhatMojo 2017 Black Meatly NEW NWT
AU $37.59
HALLMARK Vtg Stationary Girls Rainbow Friendship Original Complete NEW Sealed
AU $203.56
WILTON Sesame Street Cookie Cutters Lot 4 Oscar Big Bird Count Birthday Muppets
AU $15.66
Boehm Nativity Ornaments Greatest Gift Jesus Mary Joseph 3pc NIB 2004
AU $106.52
Baby Gund Rainbow Brightbear Plush Rattle Vtg 8" Stuffed Red
AU $43.84
Crown Royal Hat Strapback Black Logo Promotional Liquor Adjustable Strap Gold
AU $21.93
Parker Brothers Famous Paintings Vtg Card Game 1916
AU $62.66
Ashland Beer Can Glass Blown 3" x 1.5" Christmas Ornament NEW Tag
AU $15.66
Coors Light Beer Hat Beige Blue Snapback Embroidered McDowell Vtg Cotton
AU $25.05
Russ Berrie TOBY Bunny Rabbit White Gray Plush Vtg 16” Stuffed No 988 Korea
AU $37.58
Animaniacs WAKKO Plush Play Vtg 14" Warner Bros 1995 Stuffed
AU $39.14
Ashland Blown Glass Doctor Physician White Coat 4" Ornament Medical Student NEW
AU $18.80
Tupperware Salad #1842 Food To Go Lunch Set Bowl & Spoon Kids Salmon Green
AU $18.80
Ty Beanie Buddies FLIP Cat White Plush 11" Soft Pink Bow Vtg 1999 Buddy Tylon
AU $46.98
Ganz Webkinz BLACK PANTHER HM216 Plush Cat 8" Stuffed NEW Sealed Code
AU $32.88
Aurora Palm Pals COSMO 5" Astronaut Space Plush White Beanbag Stuffed
AU $12.52
Raggedy Ann and Andy Dolls 24” Vtg Handmade Large Cloth EUC
AU $56.39
Buxton Wallet Bifold Black Organizer Leather Exterior 8" x 4" Zip Card Snap
AU $23.48
Pepsi Sylvester Cat Tweety Bird 1976 Looney Tunes Bulldog Collector Glass
AU $17.21
Montana Lifestyles Boot Western Cowboy Ornament Silversmiths NEW
AU $18.80
Holly Hobbie Toy Kitchen Lot 20+ Dishes Plates Cups Pitcher Lids Vtg Retro
AU $34.46
Annalee Lady Caroler Vtg 1997 Christmas Dickens Holiday 11" Woman Sing Green
AU $31.33
Mattel Barbie Wedding Fashions Dress 1979 Vtg Here Comes Bride 1416 White Lace
AU $31.33
Old World Christmas Pugsley Pug Dog OWC 2.5" Blown Glass Ornament 2004 NEW
AU $21.93
About us
Pupster Picker is named after my daughter's favorite plush and born out of my passion for thrifting. Hand chosen goods in my store are picked from antique malls, thrift stores and community sales giving a second life to vintage items! I am passionate about reuse and upcycling as a way to protect the environment and promote a sustainable lifestyle. To receive future promotions and sales notifications, please consider following and listing my store as a favorite. I list 4-6 new items in my store daily! My favorite items to source are vintage stuffed animals, toys from the 80s & 90s, Christmas decor and collectibles.
Seller feedback (1,201)
- o***l (1495)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseA+++++great seller, fast shipping, packaged well, items as described, good value!!
- o***e (638)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseBEAUTIFUL QUILT BLANKET SOFT JUST AS DESCRIBE SHIPPING WAS FAST LOVE THE PACKING WITH CARE AND THE VALUE WAS VERY REASONABLE AND AFFORDABLE, WILL DEFINITELY BUY FROM SELLER
- e***o (1656)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseOutstanding eBay Seller in all respects! Excellent customer service, lightning fast shipping, and a fairly priced item that was exactly as described (and packed so well)!
- o***8 (32)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseThe shipping was fast and reliable. Order it and it came within 5 days. The packaging was secured and the item came in as described. The value was great for a toy I had when I was a kid. Very happy with my purchase.
- y***t (146)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseBeautiful elephant. As described. Very well packaged. Fair price. Shipped fast.
- h***i (119)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseFast shipment, packaged securely. Kit is as described and definitely priced nicely.