Featured categories
All items
SSC: New 15" Rudy Orange Plush Abby's Stepbrother Blue Hair Sesame Street Place
AU $86.20
New 20" Guy Smiley Reporter Plush Sesame Place St Classic Blue Jacket
AU $96.23
New 10" Baby Alice Snufflupagus Plush Sesame St Place Classic Character Snuffy
AU $69.27
SSC: New 12" Slimey Worm Poseable Plush Oscar Grouch Pet Sesame Street 3Y+
AU $38.48
New Sesame Street Rosita Plush 16" Green Spanish Grl Monster 2025 Rare Soft Eyes
AU $96.23
New 12" Small Pink Gonger Chef Plush on Cookie's Food Truck Sesame Street Place
AU $55.41
New 1.5" Sherlock Hemlock Pin Sesame Place Street Ace Detective Holmes
AU $33.86
Sesame St Collectors: New 1.25" Red Orange Frazzle Monster Pin Ses Place Classic
AU $32.32
Sesame Street Collectors: 1.5" T Purple Two-Headed Monster Pin S Place Classic
AU $33.10
Vintage 3" L Barkley PVC Orange White Dog Sesame Street Applause
AU $23.08
Core Slimey Worm Pin With Baseball Cap Hat & Sunglasses Shades Sesame Street
AU $36.94
Sesame Street Girl Power! New 2.75" Prairie Dawn & Rosita & Zoe PVC Figures
AU $69.27
Elmo & Zoe Party Parade Pin Sesame Street Place - Detailed Float Tree Flowers
AU $34.64
New 14" Small Super Grover Plush Sesame Street Place Cape Helmet Cute Hero 2023
AU $56.20
Cute New 13" Furry Green Dinger Plush 2022 NWT Sesame Street Place
AU $55.41
New 12" Julia Plush Sesame Street Place Autistic Girl Red Hair Pink Shirt
AU $55.41
New XL Yip Yips Boo Martian T-Shirt Halloween Ghosts Glow In Dark Sesame Street
AU $53.87
New 1.5" Abby Cadabby Fancy Medallion Pin Sesame Street Place S. 2 Waves Wand
AU $38.48
6 Window Pane Pins: Elmo Cookie Count Betty Lou Ernie/Bert & Big Bird Sesame St
AU $92.36
New 15" Elmo Swim Plush Red Guy Sesame Street Place Suit Shades Glasses
AU $61.57
SSC: New 15" Slimey Worm Plush Oscar Grouch Pet Place Rare Sesame Street
AU $104.68
New 1.5" Grover Fancy Medallion Pin Sesame Street Place - G Waves Out - Series 2
AU $38.48
New 15" Pink Telly Monster Plush 2025 Soft Eyes Sesame Street Place Seaworld
AU $92.36
New 1.25" Baby Alice Snufflupagus Pin Sesame Street Classic Girl Sister Snuffy
AU $33.86
New 14" Bert & 13" Ernie Plush Sesame Place Street 2024 & 2022 Huggable Duo
AU $88.53
12" Holiday Elmo Singing Plush 12 Days Christmas - In Box- Sesame Street 2004
AU $76.97
New 5" Elmo Plush Shoulderkins Sesame Street - Magnetic Toy
AU $43.88
2XL Adult Gray Sesame Street Sweatshirt 9 Characters Elmo Grover Slimey Exc Cond
AU $30.78
1.5" Count Von Count Fancy Medallion Pin S 2 Sesame Street Place - 3 Fingers Up
AU $38.48
Cookie's Monster Land Pin Sesame Place Street - Retired Pin - Cookie Jar
AU $30.78
New Cute 1.5" T Herry Monster Pin Sesame Street Place Classic Rare Character
AU $30.78
2 New Sesame Street PVC Figures: Snuffleupagus - Snuffy - & Count Von Count
AU $46.96
10" Pink Teena Tina Japan Sesame Street Plush Puppet Box Takara Tomy 2005 Rare
AU $138.55
New 18" Sherlock Hemlock Plush Sesame Place St Classic Character Detective 2025
AU $95.44
New Baby Bear & Slimey Pin In Sesame Street Neighborhood Window Pane S Place
AU $35.40
Happy Birthday To Little Slimey Pin September 2020 Calendar Sesame Street Place
AU $38.48
New 1.5" Oscar Grouch Fancy Medallion Pin Sesame Street Place S. 2 Folded Arms
AU $38.48
2" Abby Cadabby Pin Halloween Witch Broom Dangling Pot Moon Sesame Street Place
AU $31.18
13" L 7" T Small Snuffleupagus Snuffy Plush Sesame Place 0M+ Soft Cute 2021
AU $53.87
New 1.5" Amazing Mumford Pin Sesame Street "A La Peanut Butter Sandwiches!" 2025
AU $32.32
15" Gund Teach Me Cookie Monster Plush Baker's Apron Sesame St 2019
AU $26.94
2 New 3" Sesame Street PVC Figures: Snuffleupagus - Snuffy - & Cookie Monster
AU $46.96
Complete Set of 8 Tiny Sesame Street 50 Years Gund Mini Plush Oscar Prairie Dawn
AU $138.55
6.25" L Sesame Street School Bus Carrying Case Storage For PVCs Small Toys
AU $26.94
13" New Purple Honker Plush Monster Sesame Street Place - Heart Shaped Tongue
AU $68.51
New 11" T Barkley Orange White Dog Sesame Street Place Classic Character Tag
AU $107.76
New 7" Two-Sided Plush Oscar Emoji Clip-On 18M+ Sesame Street Place Angry Laugh
AU $32.32
New 15" Abby Swim Plush Girl Fairy Sesame Street Place Cadabby Suit Wand
AU $73.13
About us
We are Sesame Street collectors, mainly of plush. After 20+ years, we need to make room! Contact us if you're looking for a particular plush -- new or old; we may have him/her!
Seller feedback (648)
- s***0 (141)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseVery awesome seller, quick shipping, fast replies, and the item I purchased was packaged very nicely and wrapped up to keep it safe. Item was exactly as described! I would recommend this seller and would purchase from them again!
- h***h (641)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseMy item arrived on time, nice packaging , the item was as the seller described at a great price, I’m happy with my purchase, thank you! I highly recommend this seller!!
- p***p (195)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseSuper fast shipping, highly protected in the packaging, great seller if you’re looking for rare Sesame Street items for a great value overall happy. The pin is super like Super Grover and perfectly described.
- 0***s (50)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseGood protective packing. Prompt shipment after purchase. Received item 4 days after purchase. Fair pricing on items.
- l***s (149)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseGreat shipping, super fast. Great packaging, as described. Great communication.
- i***t (1087)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseI am very happy with this purchase. My son loves Cookie Monster and he was so happy to get this in the mail. My order was packaged with care and arrived sooner than expected. Item arrived as described and was purchased at a great price. Thanks!!